I’m going to just come out and say it: I don’t mind Taylor Swift’s new song. This fact in itself really shouldn’t be something worthy of shame, but there you go. True, I’m not a big fan of pop music, which makes sense because, having 27 years under my belt, I’m not the target market for that kind of thing. (One Direction who? Just kidding; people who act as though they don’t know who Harry Styles is, in order to gain some kind of indie credential, are liars. Enormous liars. But I digress.) But although I’d generally give pop a miss, this shouldn’t mean that, in the breaks between being a high-flying career woman, balancing adulthood, love, life and having it all, I can’t unfold myself from the foetal position on the kitchen floor (being a grown up is tough) and temporarily fool my mind into submission with a song that is simply a 2-minute slice of fun.
I hate the attitude that one kind of music is intrinsically better than another. I hate the attitude that people who like a particular type of popular culture are somehow beneath others. I hate that you must label your enjoyment of an ‘uncool’ band as a ‘guilty pleasure’, lest you become blinded by the sneers of derision from your hip mates.
What I’m getting at, in a roundabout way, is this. There’s this meme doing the rounds at the moment comprising a photo of Taylor Swift beside a photo of Adele, a caption bleating: ‘Same age. One is a mom. One is mentally stuck in middle school.’
Oh boy. Where to start?
There are a few things that are bothersome about this particular wannabe takedown of the chirpy songstress. There’s the implication that Adele is somehow better than Swift, as, although they are both globally successful singer-songwriters, Adele ‘wins’ for also having reached that nadir that every girl is expected to hold above all other – she’s had a baby.
[It was here that I took a break to consult my bud Wiki to confirm each singers’ age and discovered that Adele, having been born on May 5th 88 is actually more than a year and a half older than T-Swizz whose birthday is Dec 13th 89, rendering this meme bollocks in its very essence, but whatever Kirstyn, this is the internet. Let’s all concentrate on being righteously indignant and worry about precise details at a later date. I’m going to keep writing because there are so many feels and they must be expressed.]
This attitude is a subset of the whole ‘you wouldn’t understand, you’re not a mother’ ideology, spread like pureed banana by a society that largely, I’d wager, still ranks those who’ve dropped a kid into the world as having fulfilled their destiny as a woman more than a woman who, god forbid, wants to sleep through the night and have a life in which they are not directly responsible for another human being and to be able to go to the bathroom without a timorous voice quavering through the door ‘when are you going to play with meeeeee?’ When I’m done weeping into the sink – that’s when. (I’ve been an au pair. It was not a good time in my life.)
This implication that, purely by dint of achieving motherhood status, Adele should be seen as worthier than Swift is that sneaky kind of ingrained misogyny that you don’t often recognise as such until it’s too late.
Then there’s the ‘mentally stuck in middle school’ tag. Taylor Swift has always been tarred with the immaturity brush, which I imagine stems from her first album reaching No 1 on the US country charts and No 5 on the US billboard charts when she was 17 years old, so, yeah, still pretty much a child herself. Is this immature vision we hold of her down to the content of the songs themselves – yes of course. Bright, peppy country-pop about boys. God forbid. It’s worth noting that the majority (but not all, because we are all different – life lesson from an unlikely source) of late teens/early 20-ishes are concerned about their relationships or lack thereof. This is not a failing in society, but surely something that music consumers find comforting in knowing there are others out there who relate to them. Some of these ‘others out there’ just happen to be Taylor Swift. Some happen to be Morrissey. It is also worth noting that it takes all sorts to make a world.
The middle school allusion might also reference her being linked to a number of high profile men throughout her career, implying somehow that by dating a lot of people, she is acting both immature and ‘slutty’. Here’s an idea: can we just quit with the slut shaming already? The litany of things that are unfair, sexist double standards about the whole notion of slut-shaming is for another article altogether, but, put succinctly: a woman’s worth should not be dictated by the number of men she has slept with. This is just plain old common sense.
I’m going to step in here and acknowledge that Swift herself isn’t innocent in the slut-shaming debate. The most obvious example a particularly mean lyric in ‘Better Than Revenge’: ‘she’s not a saint and she’s not what you think/she’s an actress/she’s better known for the things that she does/on the mattress,’ however I’m going to step right up and argue that this is what we call a vicious circle. If you call a girl out on her sexual activity often enough, the practice becomes normalised and, after a while, an unconscious knee-jerk convention. It’s also a shame because ‘actress’ simply does not rhyme with ‘mattress’.
What struck me most, however, was: ‘We’re happy, free, confused and lonely in the best way/it’s miserable and magical.’ Slap a minor key, slowed-down melody and a different, cooler, band’s mouthpiece on that and they’d be taken more seriously than they are having sprung from Swift’s pen. So it’s not the deepest or most inspirational set of lyrics, but, in the context of mainstream poppiness, it’s refreshing to have someone sum up that mixed bag of 20-somethings’ flailing emotional state in a pretty blithe way.










